Federal
heads
in
the
sand:(
The
Dear
Colleague
letter
written
by
Acting
Deputy
Director,
Epidemiology
and
Surveillance
Division,
National
Immunization
Program,
CDC
October
27,
1998
NEEDLE
SAFETY
IS
TOPIC
OF
ARTICLES
PUBLISHED
IN
THE
SAN
FRANCISCO
CHRONICLE
Two
3-part
series
of
articles
on
needle
safety
were
published
in
1998
by
the
San
Francisco
Chronicle.
The
first
series,
"Deadly
Needles,"
caught
the
attention
of
readers
by
claiming
that
"one
million
health
care
workers
each
year
are
injured
by
needle
sticks
-
more
than
100,000
of
them
in
California."
The
second
series,
"The
Invisible
Epidemic,
1920-87,"
began
with
an
article
on
health
risks
associated
with
the
use
of
contaminated
needles
and
resulted
in
the
publication
of a
"Dear
Colleague"
letter
from
the
Centers
for
Disease
Control
and
Prevention
(CDC).
Related
Articles:
October 27, 1998 SFGate DEADLY NEEDLES Fast Track to Global Disaster Reynolds Holding, William Carlsen, Chronicle Staff Writers- For decades, researchers warned that contaminated syringes could transmit deadly viruses with cruel efficiency. But efforts to defuse the crisis were failed, and today, it has become an insidious global epidemic, destroying millions of lives every year.
Unsafe injections in the developing world and transmission of bloodborne pathogens: a review- ...Five studies attributed 20-80% of all new infections to unsafe injections...major mode of transmission of hepatitis C... occur routinely
The
letter,
dated
October
27,
1998,
was
written
by
Ben
Schwartz,
MD,
Acting
Deputy
Director,
Epidemiology
and
Surveillance
Division,
National
Immunization
Program,
CDC,
and
read
as
follows:
Dear
Colleague:
Earlier
today,
the
San
Francisco
Chronicle
and
San
Francisco
Examiner
released
the
first
of a
three-part
story
on
the
health
risks
associated
with
use
of
contaminated
needles...
The
article
focuses
on
problems
in
the
developing
world,
quoting
an
unpublished
WHO
study
suggesting
that
10
million
infections
and
1.8
million
deaths
occur
annually
from
infections
such
as
HIV
and
hepatitis
B
and
C
that
are
spread
by
contaminated
needles.
The
article
also
focuses
on
warnings
that
were
ignored,
information
that
was
not
disseminated,
and
new
technologies
that
were
slow
to
be
introduced.
Because
this
article
may
raise
concern
about
injections
associated
with
immunization
in
the
United
States,
we
wanted
to
alert
you
to
this
issue
and
to
offer
some
messages
that
can
be
communicated
to
concerned
persons
or
the
media.
The
Advisory
Committee
on
Immunization
Practices
(ACIP)
states
in
their
general
recommendations
that,
"Syringes
and
needles
used
for
injections
must
be
sterile
and
preferably
disposable
to
minimize
the
risk
of
contamination.
A
separate
needle
and
syringe
should
be
used
for
each
vaccination."
(MMWR
1994;43,RR-1)
The
conditions
described
in
the
San
Francisco
Chronicle
article
which
result
in
spread
of
infection
--
poverty
and
ignorance
--
are
not
relevant
to
immunization
delivery
in
the
United
States
today.
The
only
U.S.
examples
of
infection
linked
with
injection
were
a
1960
outbreak
of
hepatitis
associated
with
non-vaccine
injections
in a
physician's
office
and
"a
hepatitis
outbreak...among
U.S.
soldiers
after
[receiving]
multiple-dose
tetanus
shots
from
reused
syringes."
Most
injections
worldwide
are
not
associated
with
immunization
but
with
injection
of
other
medications.
Severe
infections
such
as
hepatitis
and
HIV
do
continue
to
occur
in
the
U.S.
among
injecting
drug
users
where
needle
reuse
still
occurs.
Rarely,
local
infections
at
the
site
of
vaccination
have
occurred
in
the
U.S.
linked
with
poor
skin
disinfection
and
rare
outbreaks
of
bacterial
infections
associated
with
contamination
of a
multi-dose
vial
have
been
reported
(e.g.,
Simon,
et
al,
Pediatr
Infect
Dis
J
1993;12:368-71).
Despite
the
uncommon
occurrence
of
adverse
effects,
vaccination
remains
an
important
disease
prevention
measure.
Millions
of
cases
of
infection
and
thousands
of
deaths
are
prevented
in
the
U.S.
each
year
because
of
immunization.
The
issue
of
injection
safety
is a
serious
problem
for
immunization
programs
in
developing
countries
due
to
scarce
funds
available
for
sterile
needles
and
syringes.
This
series
of
articles
does
a
service
by
drawing
attention
to
this
issue.
But
the
solutions
are
not
easy
for
public
health
ministries
facing
severe
resource
shortages.
(END
OF
LETTER)
All
of
the
articles
in
both
of
the
San
Francisco
Chronicle
series
on
needle
safety
are
on
the
web.
To
read
and/or
download
any
or
all
of
the
articles,
click
here:
http://www.sfgate.com/news/special/pages/1998/04/needles/
----